Cheese!
March 9th, 2010
One of the things I bust out when I talk about how crafty I am or how into eating local I am is that I like to make my own cheese. Through one of my various blog obsessions, I found the link to this yogurt cheese recipe. Since last night we were going to an Oscar party and had bought 3 giant tubs of greek yogurt from Costco on Friday, I thought I’d give it a try.
First, this recipe is damn simple. Place cheesecloth in a sieve, put sieve on top of mixing bowl, let sit in fridge for 2 hours, squeeze excess whey out of cheese cloth, put into bowl, mix with seasoning. What happens is that all of the excess whey drains out of the yogurt through the cheesecloth, leaving only milk solids. The result is a tangy cheese about the consistency of cream cheese or a spreadable goat cheese. And if you use low fat or no fat yogurt, you’ve got a low calorie treat! Heck, use full fat yogurt, it’s still good for you. The teaspoon of olive oil I added to the final result probably added some calories, but not enough to care. I used Fage greek yogurt, but that was only because we had a bunch on hand. You could use plain storebought yogurt or homemade yogurt. (Though if you use homemake yogurt, it’ll probably have to drain for longer than 2 hours, since homemade yogurt is usually runnier than storebought)
Once you have your yogurt cheese out of the cheese cloth, wash your cheesecloth! Then, season your cheese to taste. Use the seasonings in the link above, or get creative! If you’ve got fresh herbs in your garden, this would be delightful with basil, rosemary, garlic, olive oil and a little bit of salt and pepper. If you want something sweeter, maybe agave syrup and roast walnuts with a touch of cinnamon. This would probably also be fun with curry powder, a jerk chicken rub, herbs de provence or Penzey’s Mural of Flavor. (If you don’t shop at Penzey’s for spices, you need to. Now.) I seasoned mostly according to recipe, though I used a smoked finishing salt I got for Christmas, used a little cayenne & cumin instead of paprika, skipped the dried onions, parsley and chives, because I didn’t have any. Still, this was easy enough and tasty enough with carrot sticks that I can’t wait to incorporate this into our usual diet.
If you’ve ever wanted to make cheese but been too intimated to try, trust me, it’s really easy. I think the thing that keeps me from making cheese the most is that it feels wrong to make it using store bought milk and not farmer’s market milk (and it tastes so. much. better. with farmer’s market milk). But this is easy, simple and delicious. And if you can do this, it’s an easy stepping stone to making your own mozzarella. The hardest part with that is getting the rennet and food grade citric acid
, but a good cooking supply store (or Amazon) will have both.





